GenAI: Rubbish, Balderdash and Poppycock

Bill Broun

Faculty Advisor

Please don’t use AI to write your research essays, your short stories, or poems. Your future self will thank you. Forget any risk of failing. If you want to succeed, you absolutely must learn to fail first, and to fail again, and again, and again.

There is no other way to learn to write.

This is partly why I always feel unsettled when fellow humanities educators see shortcuts and get overly excited about AI writing technology. I’ve seen this before. With every wave of digital innovation in the last 40 years has come waves of early-adopters in the humanities who bought the hype.

They scolded the slow adopters. They pushed for bigger tech budgets in the humanities. They poo-pooed the stodgy professors of yore with their physical dusty books and Yorick-skull paperweights.

But the stodgy professors understood the value of the slow and embarrassing “long-cut” scenic route in writing.

I understand why, in the realms of the sciences, mathematics and engineering, AI has left people astounded. And I know all about the worth of digital technology in the humanities for data analysis, archiving, compiling, retrieving and organizing information. Sure. I get all that.

But for writing? Count me out.

I have not seen a single AI-generated poem, short story, essay or novel excerpt that impressed me as imaginative work. Not one.

It’s all rubbish. Every bit of it. Bin it, please.

“Rubbish” and “bin it,” you ask? Why would I write those words?

Because my father is an immigrant from the British Midlands, and those phrases live there in human hearts to this day, and I care about them. Not as much as I care about coffee in the morning, but a bit.

I could have used balderdash, bullshit, codswallop, poppycock all for the same purpose, but the noun rubbish and the use of bin as a transitive verb are tied to my own unique story, and today, during an afternoon thunderstorm, with a chill in the air, and my bodily caffeine quotient fading, rubbish and bin, it felt right.

Ask me tomorrow, rain or snow, and I may use “cack” and “get rid”—two other Britishisms that would serve the same purpose as rubbish and bin. And I may have a fever. Or be depressed and lonely. Or need my Honda’s tire repaired. I’m a big mess, after all.

AI will never grasp the mysteries of messy human experience. It can only simulate them, and it doesn’t even do that very well.

This is where some clever people often offer what they think is a brilliant counter-argument: Why not just train AI to write in your own voice?

I’ll tell you why. That’s the great self-delusion of a thousand bad writers. Not only are students turning to AI to “write in their own voice” or “humanize” this or that piece of AI bunk, but college graduates who ought to know better remain intoxicated with the notion that super crafty AI use can allow writers essentially to create a secret “Me” button they can just push at will to give any piece of writing their own specially personal touch.

But dedicated writers know this is a lie.

Every new word I write changes the way I think. The ancient Greek philosopher Heraclitus of Ephesus once asserted, “ποταμῷ γὰρ οὐκ ἔστιν ἐμβῆναι δὶς τῷ αὐτῷ,” which means, roughly, that you can’t step into the same river twice. The river of words, like the mind, is constantly in flux for genuine writers. You never know where it will take you. How can you?

How can you teach AI to imitate a voice that is itself unknown to the writer inside, that is forever just out of reach?

In the realm of creative writing, good editors aren’t fooled. They’re catching the fakes. I’ve seen grotesque simulations of imagination that seem to dupe a lot of readers, but no truly engrossing work. Not even once.

What about writing that’s supposed to be boring, you ask? Instructional manuals, annual corporate reports, legal summaries and the like? Doesn’t AI writing work for those?

Others may differ with me, but my answer remains an emphatic hell no.

Writing instructions, reports and summaries trains the mind. As the late, great comp and rhetoric theorist and teacher Donald Murray once wrote, “Writing is a way of thinking on paper.”

Who ever said writing was just about product? The journey .. no, wait … that’s an awful cliché. Getting to the end of the song isn’t what makes music magical. Listening through constellations of notes is what teaches us joy. Even writing a paragraph on how to peel a grape offers my mind discoveries of green translucent grape flesh.

As an English professor, I want your real voice, not the genericized, cliché-ridden, colorless polished rubbish of Chat or Gemini or Claude, but even more, I want to nurture the process of thinking and learning in you. I want to see the human in you rise and learn how to learn for yourself.

College is nothing if not an education in education itself.

These days, in fact, I find myself treasuring student errors and little writing “failures.” In the past, a comma splice or a sentence fragment used to feel to me like a bleeding paper cut on a student paper—an ugly thing that made me wince. Nowadays, these errors feel like gold nuggets fished out of the stream of AI slop. I grab them out of an essay, and I and the students hold them up to the sun and gaze like gaunt prospectors. “Thar’s gold in these hills,” we say. Evidence of humanity. It’s a gorgeous thing—a learning human being.

No wonder why AI continues to feel threatening to real writers. I’m not worried about losing my job as an English professor. I’m more worried about losing our ability to make mistakes, for it is in these that we grow.

Bill Broun is faculty advisor to the Stroud Courier.




The views expressed in the Opinion section do not reflect the views of the Stroud Courier, its editorial board or East Stroudsburg University, but are solely the views of the author.